Major League Baseball Grading: 10 Biggest MLB Signings At All-Star Break
This past MLB offseason saw historic signings, including the largest contract in baseball history, with teams splurging on starting pitching. As we reach the 2025 MLB All-Star Break, let’s assess how these signings have performed so far.
OF Juan Soto – New York Mets
Contract: 15-year, $765 million deal
2025 stats: 23 home runs, 56 RBIs, 77 walks, .262/.396/ fc188 casino login.509 slash line, 3.9 WAR (423 plate appearances)
Juan Soto’s $765 million deal with the Mets is the largest in MLB history. While he’s a decent fielder, he is not elite and has mediocre baserunning skills, making it difficult for him to meet his $51 million average annual salary. Soto’s value is reflected in helping the Mets secure multiple championships, performing consistently as a top-tier hitter in both regular and postseason. After a slow start, he has been swinging strongly this season, performing as the elite and impactful hitter he has always been.
Grade: B
LHP Max Fried – New York Yankees
Contract: Eight-year, $218 million deal
2025 stats: 11-3, 2.43 ERA, 1.01 WHIP, 113 strikeouts, 122.0 innings pitched, 3.3 WAR (20 starts)
Following Soto’s departure after a successful season with the Yankees, Fried became their first big signing and has proven his worth. The left-hander has delivered exceptional performances, pitching deep into games and showing versatility with his six-pitch mix. With injuries to Gerrit Cole and other key pitchers, Fried has stepped up as the Yankees’ ace. His presence has been crucial for the team.
Grade: A
RHP Corbin Burnes – Arizona Diamondbacks
Contract: Six-year, $210 million deal
2025 stats: 3-2, 2.66 ERA, 1.17 WHIP, 63 strikeouts, 64.1 innings pitched, 2.2 WAR (11 starts)
The Diamondbacks made a significant investment in Burnes, who showcased his prowess as their ace before a June elbow injury led to Tommy John surgery, cutting his season short. His injury raises concerns about his future contributions, making his contract a potential burden moving forward.
Grade: D+
LHP Blake Snell – Los Angeles Dodgers
Contract: Five-year, $182 million deal
2025 stats: 1-0, 2.00 ERA, 2.00 WHIP, four strikeouts, 9.0 innings pitched, -0.2 WAR (two starts)
Snell, known for his electrifying talents, has faced significant injury challenges throughout his career. This season, his shoulder injury has sidelined him after just two starts. The Dodgers have struggled with pitching injuries, and a healthy Snell could be the key to their postseason success okebet.com.ph. However, his hefty contract has yet to produce results.
Grade: C-
SS Willy Adames – San Francisco Giants
Contract: Seven-year, $182 million deal
2025 stats: 12 home runs, 48 RBIs, 45 walks, .220/.307/.373 slash line, 0.9 WAR (408 plate appearances)
Adames excelled with the Brewers before joining the Giants, but he has struggled to find his rhythm this season. Although he showed improvement in July, his overall performance has been below expectations in his first year with San Francisco.
Grade: C-
3B Alex Bregman – Boston Red Sox
Contract: Three-year, $120 million deal
2025 stats: 11 home runs, 35 RBIs, 22 walks, . jilihot app download298/.380/.546 slash line, 2.9 WAR (234 plate appearances)
Bregman had a stellar career with the Astros before joining the Red Sox, where injuries have hindered his performance. He has shown flashes of his capabilities, and the team’s recent success aids his grade. However, the internal turmoil with Rafael Devers complicates his situation.
Grade: B-
OF/DH Anthony Santander – Toronto Blue Jays
Contract: Five-year, $92.5 million deal
2025 stats: Six home runs, 18 RBIs, 24 walks, .179/.273/.304 slash line, -0.9 WAR (209 plate appearances)
Santander seemed like a steal after a strong 2024 season but has faltered this year, struggling with a high strikeout rate and injuries. Even with the Blue Jays atop the AL East, his underwhelming numbers reflect poorly on this signing.
Grade: D+
LHP Sean Manaea – New York Mets
Contract: Three-year, $75 million deal
2025 stats: 0-0, 2.70 ERA, 1.50 WHIP, seven strikeouts, 3.1 innings, 0.0 WAR (one appearance)
After recovering from an elbow injury, Manaea made his season debut in July. His long absence is one of many injury woes for the Mets’ rotation. If he returns to form quickly, his impact could improve this grade significantly.
Grade: D
RHP Nathan Eovaldi – Texas Rangers
Contract: Three-year, $75 million deal
2025 stats: 7-3, 1.58 ERA, 0.85 WHIP, 94 strikeouts, 91.0 innings pitched, 3.4 WAR (16 starts)
Eovaldi has been remarkable post-re-signing, delivering Cy Young-worthy performances. His versatility and command have made a tremendous impact on the Rangers’ success this season jili22 vip 2.
Grade: A+
LHP Tanner Scott – Los Angeles Dodgers
Contract: Four-year, $72 million deal
2025 stats: 4.09 ERA, 19 of 26 in save opportunities, 1.14 WHIP, 49 strikeouts, 44.0 innings pitched, 0.0 WAR (45 appearances)
Scott’s performance has dipped this season after two stellar years, leading to severe struggles in save opportunities. phdream online A successful postseason could bolster his grade, but his early season woes raise concerns.
Grade: C
What are your thoughts on these player signings and their performance at the All-Star Break?